2001
CTOS Annual Meeting Posters— Surgery
THE VALUE OF POPULATION
BASED RESEARCH IN SOFT TISSUE SARCOMA (STS)
Chris J de Gara, Juanita Hatcher, Doug Dover, George
Dundas, Guy Lavoie, Robert Turner
The Cross Cancer Instiute, University of Alberta
OBJECTIVE: Because of the heterogeneity and rarity of STS,
Level I evidence is largely lacking and this results in a variety
of treatment approaches. Population Based Outcomes Research may be
of value in STS management as it is generalizable, includes and follows
all patients and avoids the selection, referrer and other biases inherent
in case series and even randomized study.
METHODS: The Alberta Cancer Registry, by law, registers
all cancers including STS, patient demographics, tumour and treatment
details and overall survival. There are two Regional Cancer Centres
(Tom Baker in Southern Alberta population 1.3M and the Cross Cancer
Institute in Northern Alberta population 1.7M).
RESULTS: Between 1990 and 1999, 380 patients (53% male;
211 Northern and 169 Southern) over the age of 18 years (mean 56
+ 18 years) were diagnosed with STS. The most common tumours were
MFH (30%), sarcoma NOS (27%), leiomyosarcoma (16%) and liposarcoma
(15%) with no significant differences between centres. Other than
pelvis n = 33 (Northern) vs. 16 (Southern) p = 0.01 and trunk n
= 17 (Northern) vs. 6 (Southern) p = 0.02, tumour location was similar
in Northern and Southern Alberta. Northern Alberta coded significantly
more high grade tumours (41%) than Southern Alberta (18%) p 0.01.
Significant treatment differences existed between Northern and Southern
Alberta: surgery + radiation + chemotherapy 5% vs. 38% p 0.0001,
surgery + radiation 30% vs. 11% p 0.0001, and surgery alone 46%
vs. 29% p 0.0001. These differences did not result in survival differences.
For limb, 5 year survival was 69% (Northern) vs. 66% (Southern)
and for non-limb was 56% (Northern) vs. 52% (Southern). These differences
were not significant. For the province as a whole the overall 5
year non-limb survival was 54% vs. limb 67% p = 0.0072.
CONCLUSION: In summary, using a population based approach
to the assessment of STS within a province, differences in treatment
and tumour grade were not associated with overall survival differences.
While local recurrence and quality of life data are not yet available,
we concluded that this approach can provide valuable insights into
the management of this complex cancer.
|